Meeting your family's insurance needs for three generations.
330 627 2525

About our Agency

Sixty years of Service
This year McFadden Insurance celebrates its 60th anniversary.

J. Percy McFadden launched the agency in 1951 in an upstairs office of the First National Bank at Carrollton. Since then, we've grown several times, and relocated to three more locations.

Today McFaddens is owned by agents Rick Truman and Chris Jones, who purchased it from agent/owners Dick Truman and Bob Jones.

Yet McFaddens also represents the hard work of a number of other local businessmen, through agencies purchased over these six decades. The Jack Moreland Agency, the E.E. Wallace Agency, the Perry Hess Agency, and the Poole Agency all became part of McFadden during Percy's time at the helm. Later, Chris and Rick purchased the Frank Chiurco agency (formerly owned by Bob Newell).

In the years since, McFadden has been a steady presence at the top of the square in Carrollton, helping families to plan for the accidents and setbacks life brings, and to recover in the times when help is needed most.

Agents and Staff

Chris Jones was born and raised in Carrollton, and graduated from CHS in 1986.  

Chris gained his original insurance experience as a claims adjuster, working in both central Ohio and western Pennsylvania. He graduated from The Ohio State University in 1990, with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration. 

Chris joined McFadden in 1992, and in 1993 purchased his share of the agency.

Chris' 12 year old daughter, Regan attends Minerva Jr. High, is active in volleyball, softball and most recently has taken up skiing.

In his spare time Chris loves to golf and do anything that involves his  daughter. He is currently President of the Carrollton Civic Club and is also a board member of the Coley’s Stag Reunion Committee. In the past he's served as President of the Carroll County Chamber of Commerce and the Carroll County YMCA board, and on numerous other committees and boards throughout the community.

Chris' love of the Buckeyes will be just a bit evident when you visit the office.

Barb Staley married husband Ralph & moved to Carrollton in the 1970s. They have two married daughters. Missy & Shane have just moved into their new house in the Carrollton area. Christy & Thatcher live in Cleveland where she works as a nurse at University Hospital. Rounding out the family are four grandkids, Maddy, Brady, Holden & Austin. Barb enjoys golfing, bowling & spending time with the grandkids.

Teresa L. Hill has lived in Carrollton almost all her life and better than half of that married to husband Randy.  They have 2 adult sons. Storm, who is a middle school teacher and engaged to Meghan.  They’re planning a summer beach wedding. And Trevor, who is a junior at Muskingum University majoring in International Business.

The Hill family enjoys their two snow dogs, Mackenzie, a Samoyed, and Bolt, a Siberian Husky.  Both are rescues.

Teresa enjoys spending time with family and friends, golfing, cheering on the Carrollton Warriors and is a huge Walt Disney World fan.

Jackie Dunlap, is the most recent member of the McFadden family, and the one perhaps most likely to talk with you first. Jackie has lived in Carrollton all her life. Married to Gene Dunlap for 17 years, they have two children. Jonathan, 14 and in the 8th grade, is on the wrestling team. Madison, 12 and in the 6th grade, plays basketball and softball.

The Dunlaps, too, have two dogs (isn't this a dog loving agency?!).

She loves spending time with family and friends.